- Case report
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
Paradoxical worsening of hypoxemia in a patient treated by noninvasive positive pressure ventilation for obesity hypoventilation syndrome with concomitant obstructive sleep apnea: a case report
Journal of Medical Case Reportsvolume 11, Article number: 234 (2017)
Noninvasive positive pressure ventilation is frequently prescribed to obese patients with obstructive sleep apnea syndrome and obesity hypoventilation syndrome. However, mechanical ventilation with a positive end-expiratory pressure can induce or worsen a right-to-left shunt through a patent foramen ovale associated with systemic hypoxemia. Thus, in obese patients treated with noninvasive positive pressure ventilation, a paradoxical worsening of hypoxemia may reveal the existence of a patent foramen ovale.
A 50-year-old African woman was referred to our sleep center for severe obstructive sleep apnea syndrome and obesity hypoventilation syndrome. Because she had alveolar hypoventilation and had failed previous obstructive sleep apnea syndrome therapy, noninvasive positive pressure ventilation was started. In May 2015, she had a normal residual apnea/hypopnea index calculated by the ventilator software with no hypoventilation. Six months later, severe hypoxemia without hypercapnia was noted. Contrast transthoracic echocardiography showed right-to-left shunt through a patent foramen ovale. This finding prompted a decrease in expiratory and inspiratory positive airway pressures, after which the ventilator software recorded a normal residual apnea/hypopnea index and the blood gas values improved.
Noninvasive positive pressure ventilation therapy for combined obstructive sleep apnea syndrome and obesity hypoventilation syndrome must be monitored by arterial blood gas measurements, both to reassess the hypercapnia and to look for worsening hypoxemia due to a patent foramen ovale.
The foramen ovale is a congenital opening between the two cardiac atria that usually closes shortly after birth but may remain patent. Thus, a patent foramen ovale (PFO) is found at autopsy in 20 to 34% of the general population . The PFO represents a channel through which unidirectional blood flow from the right venous blood to the left oxygenated arterial system may occur. The passage of blood from the venous blood into the left arterial blood without lung oxygenation is named right-to-left shunt. It may be associated with hypoxemia, defined in terms of reduced oxygen pressure in the systemic arterial blood (PaO2), as detected by an arterial blood gas (ABG) measurement at rest.
Right atrial pressures are elevated in patients with pulmonary hypertension (PH), which may be primary or secondary to another condition such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS) , and enhance the chance of a right-to-left intracardiac shunt through the foramen ovale. Of 48 patients with OSAS, 33 (69%) had a PFO detectable by contrast transesophageal echocardiography (TEE), compared to only 4 (17%) of 24 controls (P < 0.0001) . Systolic pulmonary artery pressure (sPAP) was significantly higher in the patients than in the controls. In the absence of right atrial pressure elevation, right-to-left shunt through the foramen ovale may occur intermittently, sometimes in relation to body position (platypnea-orthodeoxia syndrome). Right atrial pressures may rise abnormally in the absence of PH, for instance during mechanical ventilation with a positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) of at least 10 cm H2O. In this situation, right-to-left shunt through the PFO worsens the systemic hypoxemia [4,5,6]. Furthermore, a peak inspiratory airway pressure of 20 cm H2O has been shown to improve the TEE detection of PFO . Finally, in a patient with tetralogy of Fallot and severe kyphoscoliosis, noninvasive ventilation paradoxically worsened the hypoxemia by increasing the right-to-left interventricular and right ventriculoatrial pressure gradients . We are not aware of previous reports of paradoxical worsening of hypoxemia due to a right-to-left shunt through a PFO in a patient chronically treated by noninvasive positive pressure ventilation (NPPV) for obesity hypoventilation syndrome (OHS) with concomitant OSAS.
A 50-year-old African woman was referred to our sleep center for a combination of severe OSAS and OHS. She had a history of systemic hypertension treated since 2010, chronic systemic lupus erythematosus with cutaneous and joint manifestations, a positive serum anticardiolipin antibody test, and Sjögren’s syndrome with lymphocytic interstitial lung disease diagnosed in 2009 and treated by an immunosuppressant and glucocorticoid until 2011.
Her body mass index was 35.6 kg/m2. Consequently, in January 2015, she underwent respiratory polygraphy (CID 102 L; Cidelec, Angers, France) to look for OSAS. Her apnea/hypopnea index (AHI) was 37/hour, indicating severe OSAS. Obstructive hypopneas predominated (Fig. 1a). Total lung capacity and forced expiratory volume in one second/vital capacity (FEV1/VC) were normal but single-breath diffusing capacity of the lungs for carbon monoxide (DLCO) was slightly decreased. ABG analysis evidenced hypoxemia and chronic hypercapnia: PaO2, 78 mmHg; carbon dioxide pressure in the systemic arterial blood (PaCO2), 48 mmHg; pH, 7.39; calculated bicarbonate level, 29 mmoL/L; and hemoglobin oxygen saturation, 94%. The combination of obesity and alveolar hypoventilation in the absence of lung or neuromuscular disease established the diagnosis of OHS.
She had previously discontinued continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) therapy due to discomfort with a feeling of suffocation. Given the alveolar hypoventilation, she was therefore started on NPPV (S9 VPAP; ResMed Corp., San Diego, CA, USA) in spontaneous timed (ST) mode, with an expiratory positive airway pressure (EPAP) of 7 cm H2O, an inspiratory positive airway pressure (IPAP) of 16 cm H2O, and a pressure support of 9 cm H2O. In May 2015, the built-in ventilator software (ResScan) reported an AHI of 5.7/hour. Duration of ventilator use was 5 hours 18 minutes. During nocturnal NPPV, mean transcutaneous carbon dioxide (PtcCO2) was 45 mmHg and mean oxygen saturation was 95%, indicating resolution of the hypoventilation. Diurnal ABG analysis confirmed this finding (PaO2, 87 mmHg; PaCO2, 43 mmHg; and pH, 7.45).
Polysomnography (Medatec; Ablis, France) during NPPV was performed in December 2015 because our patient reported sleeping poorly. The results showed excellent upper airway patency (AHI, 1/hour); periodic limb movements with an index of 16.9/hour, resulting in sleep fragmentation with a microarousal/arousal index of 15/hour; and a mean oxygen saturation of 92.2%.
In late December 2015, shortly after the polysomnography, she reported worsening exertional dyspnea. ABG analysis was performed to assess this symptom and as part of the routine monitoring of alveolar hypoventilation. Her hypoxemia had worsened (PaO2, 53.7 mmHg), whereas PaCO2 and pH were normal (42.8 mmHg and 7.43 respectively). She was admitted with transient nasal oxygenotherapy. Computed tomography pulmonary angiography showed dilatation of her pulmonary artery with no evidence of pulmonary embolism. During saline-contrast transthoracic echocardiography with and without Valsalva maneuvers, early passage of over 30 bubbles into the left side of her heart was noted, suggesting PFO (Fig. 2). Her left ventricular ejection fraction was normal and the estimated sPAP was 50 mmHg. Nasal oxygenotherapy was stopped after the diagnosis of PFO and she was monitored in the hospital for a few days, during which her pulse oximetry values improved, suggesting intermittent opening of the foramen ovale.
In January 2016, sPAP value was again estimated at 50 mmHg, confirming the diagnosis of PH, which was ascribed to left-sided heart disease. The finding by computed tomography of smooth septal thickening in a perihilar and gravitational distribution prompted a diuretic challenge. After the treatment, transthoracic echocardiography showed normal sPAP (35 mmHg) and left ventricular ejection fraction, confirming the diagnosis of pulmonary edema.
Given the right-to-left shunt through a PFO, the NPPV parameters were changed in January 2016: the EPAP was decreased to 6 cm H2O and the IPAP to 12 cm H2O. In August 2016, the ventilator software reported a normal AHI of 3.4/hour (Fig. 1b) and ABG showed a mild hypercapnia and no hypoxemia (PaO2, 85 mmHg and PaCO2, 45.7 mmHg). These blood gas values have remained unchanged for several months (Table 1).
That mechanical ventilation with PEEP can induce or worsen a right-to-left shunt through a PFO is well documented [4, 5]. In contrast, to the best of our knowledge, a single study has assessed the hemodynamic effects of noninvasive ventilation in patients with OHS, and it had only 30 patients . Right ventricular overload was found in 43.3% of patients, that is, slightly above the 20 to 40% prevalence of PH reported in isolated OSAS [10, 11]. After 6 months of NPPV, there was a significant decrease in sPAP . This result requires confirmation in larger studies.
In our patient, OHS and OSAS may have contributed to the PH. The sPAP decline induced by diuretic therapy suggests left-sided heart disease. The mechanism by which PH secondary to left-sided heart disease may have contributed to induce right-to-left shunt through the PFO, leading to a paradoxical aggravation of the hypoxemia, remains unknown. In a patient who had OHS and OSAS with a history of unsuccessful NPPV, closure of the PFO dramatically improved the hypoxemic respiratory failure . In our patient, NPPV probably further increased the right atrial pressure, reversing the pressure gradient between the two atria and inducing right-to-left shunt through the PFO. Furthermore, the PaO2 fluctuations during NPPV treatment in our patient were consistent with intermittent opening of the foramen ovale suggesting that the balance of pressures between the right side and the left side of her heart was very unsteady. It would have been interesting to perform sequential bubble tests in increasing EPAP and IPAP values (under adequate monitoring in an intensive care unit; ICU) to provide definite proof of our hypothesis, but we did not carry out this test because of ethical considerations.
In conclusion, NPPV therapy for combined OSAS and OHS requires ABG monitoring both to evaluate the course of the hypercapnia and to look for paradoxical worsening of the hypoxemia due to right-to-left shunt through a PFO, particularly as very high pressures may be needed to correct the hypoventilation.
Arterial blood gas
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Continuous positive airway pressure
Diffusing capacity of the lungs for carbon monoxide
Expiratory positive airway pressure
Forced expiratory volume in one second/vital capacity
Intensive care unit
Inspiratory positive airway pressure
Noninvasive positive pressure ventilation
Obesity hypoventilation syndrome
Obstructive sleep apnea syndrome
- PaCO2 :
Carbon dioxide pressure in the systemic arterial blood
- PaO2 :
Oxygen pressure in the systemic arterial blood
Positive end-expiratory pressure
Patent foramen ovale
- PtcCO2 :
Transcutaneous carbon dioxide
Systolic pulmonary artery pressure
Hagen PT, Scholz DG, Edwards WD. Incidence and size of patent foramen ovale during the first 10 decades of life; an autopsy study of 965 normal hearts. Mayo Clin Proc. 1984;59:17–20.
Bancal C, Arnoult F, Krapf L, Bonay M. Patent foramen ovale and hypoxaemia with or without elevated right heart pressures. Rev Mal Respir. 2011;28:967–77.
Shanoudy H, Soliman A, Raggi P, Liu JW, Russell DC, Jarmukli NF. Prevalence of patent foramen ovale and its contribution to hypoxemia in patients with obstructive sleep apnea. Chest. 1998;113:91–6.
Cujec B, Polasek P, Mayers I, Johnson D. Positive end-expiratory pressure increases the right-to-left shunt in mechanically ventilated patients with patent foramen ovale. Ann Intern Med. 1993;119:887–94.
Pick RA, Handler JB, Murata GH, Friedman AS. The cardiovascular effect of positive end-expiratory pressure. Chest. 1982;82:345–50.
Lemaire F, Richalet JP, Carlet J, Brun-Buisson C, MacLean C. Postoperative hypoxemia due to opening of a patent foramen ovale confirmed by a right atrium-left atrium pressure gradient during mechanical ventilation. Anesthesiology. 1982;57:233–6.
Konstadt SN, Louie EK, Black S, Rao TL, Scanlon P. Intraoperative detection of patent foramen ovale by transesophageal echocardiography. Anesthesiology. 1991;74:212–6.
Jullien V, Benhamou M, Lanfranchi P, Perrin C. Increase in right-to-left intracardiac shunt with non-invasive ventilation. Rev Mal Respir. 2005;22:321–3.
Castro-Añón O, Golpe R, Pérez-de-Llano LA, López González MJ, Escalona Velasquez EJ, Pérez FR. Haemodynamic effects of non-invasive ventilation in patients with obesity-hypoventilation syndrome. Respirology. 2012;17:1269–74.
Bady E, Achkar A, Pascal S, Orvoen-Frija E, Laaban JP. Pulmonary arterial hypertension in patients with sleep apnoea syndrome. Thorax. 2000;55:934–9.
Sajkov D, Wang T, Saunders NA, Bune AJ, Neill AM, Douglas MR. Daytime pulmonary hemodynamics in patients with obstructive sleep apnea without lung disease. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1999;159:1518–26.
Mehrotra AK, Cork DP, Weiss SA, Shah AP. Dramatic improvement in hypoxemic respiratory failure after patent foramen ovale closure in a patient with obesity hypoventilation syndrome. Cardiovasc Revasc Med. 2012;13:295–7.
We thank the patient who generously provided consent to publish her medical history to help other patients.
There was no funding for writing this article.
Availability of data and materials
All data are available in the electronic medical records of our hospital, accessible to the treating medical doctors.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
Written informed consent was obtained from the patient for publication of this case report and any accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.