Incomplete punctal canalization -a balloon variant of the external membrane: a case report
Journal of Medical Case Reports volume 8, Article number: 120 (2014)
Incomplete punctal canalization is an uncommon congenital disorder characterized by a dysgenetic punctum with membranes. External membranes, the most common type of incomplete punctal canalization are flat and overlie the punctum as a veil. We describe a newer variant of incomplete punctal canalization, its clinical profile, diagnostic criteria and management.
A 9-year-old Indian boy presented with watering of his right eye since birth. His right eye lower punctal area showed an avascular translucent elevation that appeared to have a smooth dome shape. An examination at high magnification showed the slopes of the dome gradually merging and contiguous with the tarsal conjunctiva. Based on a very high degree of suspicion, an impression of atypical external membrane variety of incomplete punctal canalization was made. Membranotomy was successful in the management of his condition.
A high degree of suspicion is the key point in the diagnosis of this variant, keeping in mind the other features described for incomplete punctal canalization- external membrane. It is possible that ballooning of these membranes may represent an evolutionary stage in the process of complete canalization and this could be the starting point for further dacryo-embryologic exploration and correlations.
Proximal lacrimal outflow dysgenesis involving the punctum and canaliculus is sparsely documented in the literature [1–6]. The term incomplete punctal canalization (IPC) was first introduced by Ali et al.. They described the largest series of IPC and classified it into an external membrane variety (IPC-EM) and one with an internal membrane (IPC-IM) . We report the clinical and diagnostic profile and management of a balloon variant of the external membrane along with the clincopathological correlation and propose that this variant be included in the subclassification of IPC-EM.
A 9-year-old healthy Indian boy presented with watering of his right eye since birth that was not associated with any discharge or swelling at the corner of the eye. There were no complaints in the left eye. His best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) was 20/20 in both eyes and the rest of his ocular examination was normal.
On examination, the lids appeared normal but the tear meniscus in his right eye was found to be elevated. An examination of the medial aspect of his upper lid revealed an agenetic punctum without any evident signs of IPC. However, the lower punctum area showed an avascular translucent elevation that appeared to have a smooth dome shape (Figure 1a). Examination at high magnification showed that the slopes of the dome gradually merged and were contiguous with the tarsal conjunctiva (Figure 1b). The architecture of the pars lacrimalis portion of his lid was normal. Based on a very high degree of suspicion, an impression of atypical IPC was made.
Our patient underwent membranotomy with a gradual tapered Nettleship’s punctum dilator (Figure 1c) as described earlier . Following membranotomy, the punctum was well seen with a good opening (Figure 1d). Probing revealed the lower canaliculus to be normal (Figure 1e) and the nasolacrimal passage was found to be patent on irrigation. The lacrimal system of the fellow eye was normal. At the three-month follow-up, the right lower punctum was found to be normal with grade 1 dye disappearance and our patient reported resolution of his epiphora.
A histopathological examination of the membrane was consistent with that of the IPC membranes reported in the literature . It showed a fibrocollagenous tissue with few vascular channels without any evidence of inflammation suggestive of fibrovascular membranes (Figure 1f).
The lacrimal passages develop along the line of the cleft between the lateral nasal process and the maxillary process of the embryonic face [6, 7]. The process of canalization begins in a 35mm embryo by apoptosis of the central cells. The entire canaliculus is canalized except near the puncta and this portion opens onto the lid surface in a 130mm embryo, before the separation of the eyelids at the seventh month of intrauterine life [3, 4, 6, 8].
The pathogenesis of punctal membranes is unknown but is believed to be due to failure of canalization of the most proximal part of lacrimal apparatus [1, 3, 7, 8]. Incomplete punctal canalization thus represents the mildest form of proximal lacrimal outflow dysgenesis [1, 7].
The IPC-EM type is described in the literature to typically cover the external surface of the puncta like a flat translucent veil in an area of an avascular dimple . However in the present case, although there was an avascular and translucent area, the dimple was characteristically absent. Instead, there was a dome-shaped elevation as elucidated in the case report. Additional help in the diagnosis was the normal architecture of the pars lacrimalis of the lower lid. There was no systemic association in the present case although there was an associated lacrimal anomaly in the form of upper punctal agenesis.
Membranotomy was found to be a useful modality of management for IPC with a functional success of 91% . Membranotomy in the present case was patent at the last follow-up with resolution of the epiphora. The histopathological examination was consistent with IPC membranes as reported in the literature .
In conclusion, a high degree of suspicion is needed for the diagnosis of this variant keeping in mind the other features described for IPC-EM. It is possible that ballooning of these membranes may represent an evolutionary stage in the process of complete canalization and this could be the starting point for further dacryo-embryologic exploration and correlations.
Written informed consent was obtained from the patient’s legal guardian for publication of this case report and any accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal.
best corrected visual acuity
incomplete punctal canalization: a congenital membranous disorder of the lacrimal punctum
incomplete punctal canalization- external membrane
incomplete punctal canalization -internal membrane.
Ahn Yuen SJ, Oley C, Sullivan TJ: Lacrimal outflow dysgenesis. Ophthalmology. 2004, 111: 1782-1790. 10.1016/j.ophtha.2004.02.011.
Cahill KV, Burns JA: Management of epiphora in the presence of congenital punctal and canalicular atresia. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 1991, 7: 167-172. 10.1097/00002341-199109000-00003.
Lyons CJ, Rosser PM, Welham RAN: The management of punctal agenesis. Ophthalmology. 1993, 100: 1851-1855. 10.1016/S0161-6420(93)31386-2.
Buerger DG, Schaefer AJ, Campbell CB: Congenital lacrimal disorders. Smith’s ophthalmic plastics and reconstructive surgery. Edited by: Nesi F, Levine MR. 1998, Philadelphia: Mosby, 649-660.
Kirk RC: Developmental anomalies of the lacrimal passages. A review of the literature and presentation of three unusual cases. Am J Ophthalmol. 1956, 42: 227-232.
Duke-Elder S: Development of ocular adnexa. System of ophthalmology, volume 1. Edited by: Duke-Elder S. 1938, St Louis: CV Mosby, 364-365.
Ali MJ, Mohapatra S, Mulay K, Naik MN, Honavar SG: Incomplete punctal canalization: the external and internal punctal membranes. Outcomes of membranotomy and adjunctive procedures. Br J Ophthalmol. 2013, 97: 92-95. 10.1136/bjophthalmol-2012-302277.
Whitnall SE: The lacrimal apparatus. The anatomy of the human orbit and accessory organs of vision. Edited by: Whitnall SE. 1921, Oxford: Oxford Univ Press, 223-252.
The authors acknowledge Hyderabad Eye Institute for funding this work. The authors also acknowledge Mr SBN Chary, Mr Gattu Naresh and Mr Sandeep Roy for help with photography and figure collaging.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
AMJ conceived of the study and drafted the manuscript. NMN helped with the drafting and critical review of the manuscript. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Ali, M.J., Naik, M.N. Incomplete punctal canalization -a balloon variant of the external membrane: a case report. J Med Case Reports 8, 120 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1752-1947-8-120