Skip to main content

Table 2 Magnetic resonance observation of cartilage repair tissue assessment: morphological magnetic resonance imaging grading and point scale of both knees 12 months postoperative

From: Direct comparison of different surgical approaches in a woman with bilateral osteochondrosis dissecans of her knees: a case report

Variables

Left knee

Right knee

1. Degree of defect repair and filling of the defect

20

15

 Complete (20)

  

 Hypertrophy (15)

  

 Incomplete

  

 >50 % of the adjacent cartilage (10)

  

 <50 % of the adjacent cartilage (5)

  

 Subchondral bone exposed

  

2. Integration of the border zone

10

15

 Complete (15)

  

 Incomplete

  

 Demarcating border visible (slit like; 10)

  

 Defect visible <50 % of the length (5)

  

 Defect visible >50 % of the length (0)

  

3. Surface of the repair tissue

5

5

 Surface intact (10)

  

 Surface damaged <50 % of depth (5)

  

 Surface damaged >50 % of depth (0)

  

4. Structure of the repair tissue

0

0

 Homogeneous (5)

  

 Inhomogeneous (0)

  

5. Signal intensity of the repair tissue

30

15

 Normal (identical to adjacent cartilage; 30)

  

 Nearly normal (slight areas of signal alteration; 15)

  

 Abnormal (large areas of signal alteration; 0)

  

6. Subchondral lamina

0

0

 Intact (5)

  

 Not intact (0)

  

7. Subchondral bone

0

5

 Intact (5)

  

 Not intact (0)

  

8. Adhesions

5

5

 No (5)

  

 Yes (0)

  

9. Effusion

5

5

 No (5)

  

 Yes (0)

  

TOTAL

75

65