Skip to main content

Table 1 Literature review: Case studies of giant parathyroid adenoma (2009–2019)

From: Giant parathyroid adenoma: a case report and review of the literature

Study*

Sex

Age, years

Side

Presentation

Ca (mmol/L)/PTH (ng/L)

Radiology

Treatment

IPTH

Dimensions (mm)

Weight (g)

Pathology

Postoperative complicationsa

Thyroidal

 Aggarwal et al., 2009 [11]

India

F

33

L

Visible swelling, palpable nodule, bone pain, R humerus and R pelvic fractures

2.65/762

US: well-defined hypoechoic lesion, posterior to left lobe thyroid

Parathyroidectomy (not specified)

95 × 50 × 35

102

Chief cell adenoma

Symptomatic hypocalcemia

 Salehian et al., 2009 [12]

Iran

F

53

R

Visible swelling, bone pain, nausea, vomiting, weight loss

3.65/1624

US neck: heteroechoic mass, inferior right lobe (2 × 4.8 × 3 cm); 99mTc-MIBI: abnormal collection of tracer in R side of neck

Neck exploration and parathyroidectomy (collar neck incision)

 —

55 × 35 × 20

30

PTA

Nil

 Sisodiya et al., 2011 [13]

India

F

52

R

Recurrent vomiting

4.25/598

US: large hypoechoic lesion in right paratracheal region with retrosternal extension

Parathyroidectomy,

low anterior cervical approach

Mentioned in discussion

39 × 20 × 17

 —

 —

Hypocalcemia

 Asghar et al., 2012 [14]

Pakistan

F

55

L

Parathyroid crisisb

Palpable nodule

5.75/1182

US: large cyst (6 × 3.7 cm) on left side with thrombosis of IJV; MIBI: cystic lesion in left side neck displacing the thyroid gland on the right; CT: large hypodense lesion left side of neck with peripheral enhancement, retrosternal extension and mass effect with deviation of trachea and thrombosis of LIJV

Parathyroidectomy T-shaped incision

10 suspicious-looking lymph nodes also removed from levels 7 and 8 (by ENT and thoracic surgery teams)

 —

110 × 70 × 60

 —

PTA with prominent cystic degeneration; no lymph node metastasis

Nil

 Vilallonga et al., 2012 [10]

Spain

F

19

L

Parathyroid crisis

3.55/1207

US: 47 × 22 mm nodule in left thyroid lobe

Hemithyroidectomy (it was intrathyroidal)

Available, not used

Max. diameter 30

70

Intrathyroidal PTA

None

Calcium IV d1, oral d2

 Neagoe et al., 2014 [1]

Romania

(3 cases)

M/F/F

57/60/33

R/L/R

C 1: Bone pain, abdominal pain, nausea, palpable nodule

C 2: Parathyroid crisis, palpable nodule

C 3: Recurrent kidney stones, brown tumor of tibia

C 1:

3.54/1780

C 2:

4.04/863

C 3:

3.15/1174

MIBI: detected adenomas in the 3 cases

Bilateral neck exploration and parathyroidectomy

Not feasiblec

C 1: 50 × 30 × 20

C 2: 55 × 40 × 30

C 1: 30.6

C 2: 35.2

C 3: > 30

2 PTA; 1 partially cystic PTA

C 1: Hungry bones syndrome

C 2: Mild hypocalcemia and hungry bones syndrome

C 3: Mild hypocalcemia

 Haldar et al., 2014 [15]

UK

F

61

L

Asymptomatic

3.17/179.2

US: 6 cm mass in L inferior cervical location; MIBI: persistent activity in same location; SPECT: tubular structure in superior mediastinum

Parathyroidectomy (selective)

4 cm left collar neck incision

 —

65 × 30 × 15

12

PTA

Nil

 Garas et al., 2015 [5]

UK

F

53

L

Bone pain, palpable nodule

3.98/4038

US: lobular well-defined hypoechoic lesion behind L lower pole of thyroid gland; MRI: left inferior PTA, extends deep into mediastinum

Parathyroidectomy (transverse cervical incision)

Done – 94% reduction in 25 minutes

Max. diameter 70

27

Chief cell PTA

Nil

 Rutledge et al., 2016 [7]

Ireland

F

21

R

Enlarging neck mass, constipation, palpable nodule

2.73/1305.1

MIBI: lesion posterior to right lobe of thyroid with concentrated tracer

R thyroid lobectomy and parathyroidectomy with level 6 neck dissection (suspected carcinoma)

 —

80 × 55 × 30

58.8

Atypical PTA

Symptomatic hypocalcemia, hungry bone syndrome

 Krishnamurthy et al., 2016 [16]

India

M

50

L

Recurrent attacks of acute pancreatitis, palpable fullness

2.77/669

CT: 6 × 4 cm mass in L paratracheal region with extension to superior mediastinum; PET–CT: isolated uptake,  left paratracheal region; MIBI: localized to L inferior parathyroid gland; Preoperative FNA-C was doned

Parathyroidectomy via transcervical approach

 —

Max. diameter 60

20

PTA

Hypocalcemia

 Castro et al., 2017 [17]

Spain

F

40

L

Asymptomatic, palpable nodule

3.35/825

US: solid lesion behind L thyroid lobe; SPECT: intense uptake, back of L thyroid lobe in early and late phases

Parathyroidectomy (not specified)

Done, 90% reduction

64 × 16 × 20

10.8

PTA

Hypocalcemia

 Sahsamanis et al., 2017 [18]

Greece

F

42

L

Abdominal pain

2.60/151

US: enlarged parathyroid gland on lower side of cervical region; MIBI: large concentrations of radiotracer in the same location

Minimally invasive parathyroidectomy

Not done

33 × 20 × 14

5.39

PTA

Nil

 Mantzoros et al., 2018 [19]

Greece

F

73

R

Neck swelling, bone pain

3.63/1629

US: hypoechoic nodule at inferior pole of the right thyroid; MIBI: hyper functioning rightlower parathyroid gland

Minimally invasive parathyroidectomy

Done, 95% reduction 20 minutes after removal

50 × 25 × 25

30

PTA

Hungry bone syndrome

Mediastinal

 Migliore et al., 2013 [8]

Italy

F

65

R

Persistent hypercalcemiae

Both elevated

CT: 7 cm mass in posterior mediastinum; MIBI: confirmed the CT finding

Video-assisted minithoracotomy

 —

 —

95

PTA

Nil

 Taghavi Kojidi et al., 2016 [20]

Iran

M

70

Mid

Anorexia, nausea, bone pain, constipation, symptomatic kidney stones, polydipsia

3.60/930

US: multiple isoechoic nodules, no parathyroid glands seen; MIBI: focal radiotracer accumulation, midline anterior chest wall; CT: soft tissue density mass, mild enhancement, anterior midline, xiphoid level

Surgical removal (not specified) f

 —

 —

75

Active parathyroid lesion

Hypocalcemia

 Pecheva et al., 2016 [21]

UK

F

72

R

Depression, severe osteoporosis (T = −3.2)

3.02/250.8

US: no parathyroid lesion; MIBI: no evidence of PTA; CT: complex cystic solid mass in the mediastinum

Parathyroidectomy via VATS

Not used, emergency

 —

19

PTA

Hoarseness, bovine cough

 Talukder et al., 2017 [22]

India

F

49

Mid

Brown tumor

14.07/1000

US: no abnormal parathyroid gland; MIBI: tracer-avid lesion in anterior mediastinum; PET-CT: ectopic parathyroid tissue in anterior mediastinum behind manubrium sterni

Parathyroidectomy via cervical collar incision and hemisternotomy

 —

40 × 30 × 20

12

Neuroendocrine cell tumor

Nil

 Garuna Murthee et al., 2018 [9]

UK

M

72

Mid

Anorexia, lethargy, abdominal cramps, constipation, weight loss

15.19/1867.1

CXR: sizeable mediastinal mass; CT: 9 cm solid cystic anterior mediastinal tumor; MIBI: heterogeneous tracer uptake in the mediastinal mass

Medial sternotomy and total thymectomy

 —

Maximum diameter 78

220

Intrathymic PTA

Nil

 Miller et al., 2019 [23]

UK

M

53

Mid

Asymptomatic renal stones

11.22/179.2

MIBI: linear region of increased intensity in the left mediastinum

Parathyroidectomy via transcervical excision

Done, 81% reduction after 10 minutes

80 × 30 × 30

30.9

PTA

Nil

  1. — not reported, cannot be inferred, C1 Case 1, C2 Case 2, C3 Case 3, CT computed tomography, CXR chest X-ray, ENT otolaryngology, F female, FNA-C fine-needle aspiration cytology, IPTH intraoperative parathyroid hormone, IJV internal jugular vein, L left, M male, Mid midline, MIBI Tc99m-sestamibi scintigraphy scan, PET positron emission tomography, PTA parathyroid adenoma, PTH fine-needle aspiration cytology, R right, SPECT single photon emission computed tomography, US ultrasound, VATS video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery
  2. * Due to space limitations, only the first author is mentioned
  3. a All of the cases had asymptomatic patients with normalized Ca and fine-needle aspiration cytology on follow up (except Haldar + Sisodya – Ca only)
  4. b Parathyroid crisis comprises anorexia, urinary frequency, severe nausea, vomiting, constipation
  5. c Done 1 hour postoperative for 2 cases, found to be normal
  6. d Preoperative fine-needle aspiration cytology showed a benign epithelial lesion that could not be further characterized
  7. e Patient had previous total thyroidectomy for goiter associated with hypercalcemic syndrome (exploration had showed four normal parathyroid glands)
  8. f Patient had previous total parathyroidectomy, thymectomy, and right hemithyroidectomy