Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparative studies in the management of gallstone ileus

From: Twice recurrent gallstone ileus: a case report

 

Enterotomy

One-stage repair

Comparison

Authors

Year

Follow-up (range) in months

N

Operative mortality

Operative morbidity

Recurrent biliary disease

N

Operative mortality

Operative morbidity

Recurrent biliary disease

Operative mortality

Operative morbidity

Recurrent biliary disease

Reisner and Cohen [1]

1994

NR

801

11.7%

NR

NR (6% RGSI)

113

16.9%

NR

NR (5.3% RGSI)

Favors E (NS)

NR

NR

Rodriguez-Sanjuan et al. [4]

1997

40 (4–96)

16

18.8%

NR

6.3%

9

33.3%

NR

22.2%

Favors E (NS)

NR

Favors E (NS)

Doko et al. [8]

2003

0.5 (0–2)

11

9.1%

27.3%

NR

18

11.1%

61.1%

NR

Favors E (NS)

Favors E (P = 0.043)

NR

Tan et al. [9]

2004

24 (8–56)

7

0.0%

57.1%

0.0%

12

0.0%

58.3%

0.0%

Equal

Favors E (NS)

Equal

  1. E enterotomy, N number, NR not reported, NS non-significant, RGSI recurrent gallstone ileus.