Remission of severe restless legs syndrome and periodic limb movements in sleep after bilateral excision of multiple foot neuromas: a case report
© Lettau et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2010
Received: 23 October 2009
Accepted: 17 September 2010
Published: 17 September 2010
Restless legs syndrome is a sensorimotor neurological disorder characterized by an urge to move the legs in response to uncomfortable leg sensations. While asleep, 70 to 90 percent of patients with restless legs syndrome have periodic limb movements in sleep. Frequent periodic limb movements in sleep and related brain arousals as documented by polysomnography are associated with poorer quality of sleep and daytime fatigue. Restless legs syndrome in middle age is sometimes associated with neuropathic foot dysesthesias. The causes of restless legs syndrome and periodic limb movements in sleep are unknown, but the sensorimotor symptoms are hypothesized to originate in the central nervous system. We have previously determined that bilateral forefoot digital nerve impingement masses (neuromas) may be a cause of both neuropathic foot dysesthesias and the leg restlessness of restless legs syndrome. To the best of our knowledge, this case is the first report of bilateral foot neuromas as a cause of periodic limb movements in sleep.
A 42-year-old Caucasian woman with severe restless legs syndrome and periodic limb movements in sleep and bilateral neuropathic foot dysesthesias was diagnosed as having neuromas in the second, third, and fourth metatarsal head interspaces of both feet. The third interspace neuromas represented regrowth (or 'stump') neuromas that had developed since bilateral third interspace neuroma excision five years earlier. Because intensive conservative treatments including repeated neuroma injections and various restless legs syndrome medications had failed, radical surgery was recommended. All six neuromas were excised. Leg restlessness, foot dysesthesias and subjective sleep quality improved immediately. Assessment after 18 days showed an 84 to 100 percent reduction of visual analog scale scores for specific dysesthesias and marked reductions of pre-operative scores of the Pittsburgh sleep quality index, fatigue severity scale, and the international restless legs syndrome rating scale (36 to 4). Polysomnography six weeks post-operatively showed improved sleep efficiency, a marked increase in rapid eye movement sleep, and marked reductions in hourly rates of both periodic limb movements in sleep with arousal (135.3 to 3.3) and spontaneous arousals (17.3 to 0).
The immediate and near complete remission of symptoms, the histopathology of the excised tissues, and the marked improvement in polysomnographic parameters documented six weeks after surgery together indicate that this patient's severe restless legs syndrome and periodic limb movements in sleep was of peripheral nerve (foot neuroma) origin. Further study of foot neuromas as a source of periodic limb movements in sleep and as a cause of sleep dysfunction in patients with or without concomitant restless legs syndrome, is warranted.
Restless legs syndrome (RLS) is a sensorimotor neurological disorder characterized by an urge to move the legs in response to uncomfortable leg sensations . While asleep, 70% to 90% of patients with RLS have periodic limb movements of sleep (PLMS). Frequent PLMS and related brain arousals as documented by polysomnography are associated with poorer quality of sleep and daytime fatigue. RLS onset in middle age (late onset RLS) is sometimes associated with neuropathic foot dysesthesias (numbness, burning and/or tingling, lancinating electric shock pains, and hypersensitivity), which are attributed to small fiber-type peripheral neuropathies . We have previously reported a case series of patients with diabetes or human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) whose dysesthesias of the feet were due to bilateral Morton's neuromas rather than neuropathy .
A neuroma is a focal enlargement of the second, third (Morton's), or fourth digital nerve in the forefoot where each nerve stretches under the deep transverse ligament between the respective adjacent metatarsal heads . Repeated nerve stress results in pathological changes of so-called entrapment neuropathy, including thickening and degenerative enlargement of the nerve and surrounding fibrous sheath into a nerve impingement mass . Early symptoms include forefoot numbness and aching while late symptoms are mainly neuropathic dysesthesias. Diagnosis is primarily symptom based plus physical findings of either metatarsal head interspace tenderness or the Mulder click sign [4, 6]. Interventional treatment consists of injections of local anesthetic mixed with either corticosteroids or 4% alcohol administered into the neuroma-containing interspace. If symptoms are severe and persistent or recurrent, neuroma excision is usually curative unless complicated by nerve regrowth and re-entrapment (stump neuroma).
When several of our patients reported both decreased RLS-type leg restlessness and improved quality of sleep after receipt of bilateral neuroma injections for neuropathic foot pains, their observations were considered potentially significant because of the known association of late onset RLS with neuropathic foot symptoms. This prompted a study of neuroma treatment in patients with RLS, including some without foot complaints. Of 15 patients with moderate to severe RLS, all of whom had bilateral physical findings of neuromas, treatment with injections or surgery resulted in sustained remission of RLS in nine with a concomitant marked improvement in subjective sleep quality and fatigue, indicating that their RLS was of peripheral (neuroma) origin . In the current report, we describe a patient with severe, refractory RLS and PLMS with brain arousals (documented by polysomnography), the remission of which was prompt and near complete after bilateral excision of multiple foot neuromas.
A 42-year-old Caucasian woman with a history of diabetes, depression, and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection first had onset of bilateral foot tingling and numbness concomitant with an episode of acute severe pancreatitis. Over the next two years her foot dysesthesias progressed to burning discomfort, lancinating electric shock pains, and hypersensitivity. Examination by her foot specialist found physical signs indicative of bilateral Morton's neuromas, including third metatarsal head interspace tenderness and Mulder's clicks in each foot. She was given a series of neuroma injections (1 ml mixture of lidocaine, bupivacaine, methylprednisolone, dexamethasone and 4% alcohol). The injections improved the symptoms but relapses prompted bilateral third interspace neuroma excision ("initial neuroma surgery") which resulted in near-complete relief of neuropathic symptoms. After 6 months relatively mild foot dysesthesias recurred but resolved after the HIV drug stavudine was stopped.
Pre/post second neuroma surgery polysomnography results
Pre-operative (Baseline) (-16 weeks)
Post-operative (+6.3 weeks)
Total sleep time (efficiency)
309 minutes (71%)
346 minutes (88%)
Respiratory events (AHI rate)
16 (3.1 events/hour)
47 (8.2 events/hour)
Periodic limb movements
Periodic limb movements with
698 (135.5 movements/hour)
19 (3.3 movements/hour)
Spontaneous arousals (rate)
89 (17.3 arousals/hour)
0 (0 arousals/hour)
Severity of evening leg restlessness, daytime fatigue, overall quality of sleep, and neuropathic forefoot numbness, burning and/or tingling, electric shock pains, and foot hypersensitivity were separately assessed with 10 cm visual analog scales, with the zero score representing no symptoms and the 10 cm score the worst imaginable severity. RLS was scored by the International RLS Rating Scale (scoring range 0 to 40 points) . Assessments of depressive symptomatology were performed using the Beck Depression Inventory II (scoring range 0 to 63 points, above 29 equals severe), sleep by the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (scoring range 0 to 21 points, poor sleep is five or greater), and fatigue by the Fatigue Severity Scale (scoring range nine to 63 points, significant fatigue is 36 or greater), and the Multidimensional Assessment of Fatigue (scoring range 1 to 50 points, two or greater equals increasing level of fatigue). The baseline polysomnographic study was repeated six weeks after the second neuroma surgery. Each sleep study included bilateral electro-oculography, sub-mental electromyography, bilateral anterior tibialis electromyography, central and occipital electroencephalography, electrocardiographic waveform, airflow and respiratory effort assessment, oximetry, and video monitoring.
Pre/post-second neuroma surgery questionnaire and rating scale results
NEUROPATHIC SYMPTOM SCORES
VAS forefoot numbness
VAS burning and/or tingling
VAS electric shock pains
VAS foot hypersensitivity
International RLS rating scale
VAS evening leg restlessness
Beck depression inventory II
VAS daytime fatigue
Fatigue severity scale
MAF Global fatigue index
SLEEP QUALITY SCORES
VAS poor quality sleep
PSQI Global score
By six months after the second neuroma surgery, her neuropathic dysesthesias had recurred to the point of requiring daily pregabalin dosing along with tramadol or oxycodone-acetaminophen. At six months her primary care physician also restarted citalopram for depression. At two years after the second neuroma surgery, her VAS scores for numbness and hypersensitivity exceeded the pre-operative baseline but scores for burning and/or tingling and lancinating electric shock pains remained about 50% or less of her baseline. Also after two years her RLS scores remained in the mild range and her scores for poor quality sleep and fatigue also remained much better than the baseline scores (Table 1). She remained off any RLS treatment except for the RLS benefiting effects of pregabalin and intermittent oxycodone or tramadol taken for foot dysesthesias.
Our patient's neuropathic foot dysesthesias first fully remitted after her initial neuroma surgery and again 5 years later after the second neuroma surgery. The first mild recurrence of dysesthesias resolved with stoppage of stavudine, a nucleoside HIV drug associated with neuropathic foot symptoms. Her HIV was fully suppressed with normal immune function throughout 10 years of treatment and was not considered to have any role in her ongoing symptoms otherwise. The remissions related to the two neuroma surgeries as well as the repeated improvements with neuroma injections indicate that her neuropathic foot dysesthesias were due to neuromas rather than small fiber neuropathy, which has been associated with diabetes and HIV infection.
Our patient clearly had RLS. Her symptoms fulfilled all the cardinal criteria for the diagnosis and her score of 36 on the 40-point International RLS rating scale was in the very severe range. The baseline polysomnogram showed a severe degree of PLMS and arousals. Over the next 4 months, despite a new regimen of drugs and additional neuroma injections, her foot dysesthesias, leg restlessness, non-restorative sleep, and fatigue all remained severe as shown by her pre-operative questionnaire and rating scale responses.
Surgery was recommended because of the severity and refractory nature of her symptoms. Excision of multiple neuromas was planned because (a) office ultrasound  documented large neuromas in the second and fourth metatarsal head interspaces in addition to stump neuromas of the third interspaces, (b) physical findings were present (Mulder's clicks in the third and fourth interspaces and tenderness in all three interspaces bilaterally), and (c) our (unpublished) neuroma injection experience has been that second and fourth interspace neuromas may contribute to neuropathic symptoms and sleep dysfunction, respectively.
Post-operatively her clinical improvement with respect to RLS symptoms, subjective sleep quality and neuropathic foot dysesthesias was immediate, and near total. That all symptoms originated peripherally from neuromas is supported by the histopathological documentation of the excised tissues and the fact she remained clinically well completely off neuropsychiatric medication for the initial six weeks after surgery. The follow-up polysomnography is notable for improved sleep efficiency and a substantial increase in REM sleep. It also documented both a marked reduction in arousals associated with PLMS and an apparent elimination of spontaneous arousals. The rapid reduction of her fatigue scores suggests that most of her fatigue was due to poor sleep quality.
We have previously proposed that the leg symptoms of RLS, and possibly also PLMS and arousals, may be due to afferent nerve impulses generated from the entrapment and compression-related digital nerve irritability and damage associated with foot neuromas , and this hypothesis is supported by the clinical and polysomnographic results from our patient. In our cumulative experience with over 100 patients with RLS, we have determined that they uniformly have bilateral foot signs or ultrasound evidence of neuromas irrespective of whether they have foot sensory symptoms or not and regardless of whether their RLS is primary or secondary, or is of early or late onset. Third interspace neuromas would likely be the major source of RLS because bilateral injections of this interspace alone can induce remission of RLS symptoms . The possible contribution to neuropathic foot symptoms and sleep dysfunction of the second and fourth interspace neuromas remains to be better delineated. That some PLMS still occurred post-operatively may reflect afferent impulses arising from her freshly cut digital nerve stumps. The eventual recurrence of mild leg restlessness and the relapse of neuropathic foot symptoms in our patient starting at seven weeks post-neuroma removal may indicate renewed nerve stump entrapment(s) as a result of digital nerve regrowth and scarring. This occurrence is the unpredictable downside of neuroma excision and it underscores the reality that current techniques for neuroma resection are not necessarily curative. However, although PLMS and arousals had likely also relapsed to some degree by two years out from the second neuroma surgery, her scores for sleep quality and fatigue remained much better than her pre-operative baseline and she has never regretted that she had had the multiple neuromas excised.
The immediate and near-complete remission of symptoms, the histopathological documentation, and the marked improvement in polysomnographic parameters together clearly indicate that our patient's severe RLS and PLMS was of peripheral nerve (foot neuroma) origin. Further study of foot neuromas as a source of PLMS and as a cause of sleep dysfunction in patients with or without concomitant RLS, is warranted.
Written informed consent was obtained from the patient for publication of this case report and any accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the journal's Editor-in-Chief.
None. There was no outside funding source for this work.
- Earley CJ: Clinical practice. Restless legs syndrome. N Engl J Med. 2003, 348: 2103-2109. 10.1056/NEJMcp021288.View ArticlePubMed
- Polydefkis M, Allen RP, Hauer P, Earley CJ, Griffin JW, McArthur JC: Subclinical sensory neuropathy in late-onset restless legs syndrome. Neurology. 2000, 55: 1115-1121.View ArticlePubMed
- Lettau LA, Gudas CJ, Blackhurst D: Bilateral Morton's neuromas: a common etiology of neuropathic foot pain and dysesthesias in diabetes and HIV infection. A preliminary report on treatment. J S C Med Assoc. 2002, 98: e221-e230.
- Teasdall RD, Saltzman CL, Johnson KA: A practical approach to Morton's neuroma. J Musculoskel Med. 1993, 10: 39-52.
- Ochoa J: The primary nerve fiber pathology of plantar neuromas: a model of chronic entrapment. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 1976, 35: 370.
- Mulder JD: The causative mechanism in Morton's metatarsalgia. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1951, 33B: 94-95.
- Lettau LA, Gudas CJ: Bilateral Morton's neuromas as an etiology of restless legs syndrome. J S C Med Assoc. 2005, 101: e341-e347.
- Gudas CJ, Mattana GM: Retrospective analysis of intermetatarsal neuroma excision with preservation of the transverse metatarsal ligament. J Foot Surg. 1986, 25: 459-463.PubMed
- Walters AS: Toward a better definition of the restless legs syndrome. The International Restless Legs Study Group. Mov Disord. 1995, 10: 634-642. 10.1002/mds.870100517.View ArticlePubMed
- Perini L, Del Borello M, Cipriano R, Cavallo A, Volpe A: Dynamic sonography of the forefoot in Morton's syndrome: correlation with magnetic resonance and surgery. Radiol Med (Torino). 2006, 111: 897-905. 10.1007/s11547-006-0088-2.View Article
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.